A report by FASCISMWATCH with the help of A.I.
Inspired by Professor Dave Explains video titled ''Avi Loeb is a fraud''
Video description :
Avi Loeb is a Harvard astronomer turned pseudoscience-peddling fraud. Since 2017 he's been spewing horseshit about how everything is aliens when it definitely isn't, just to sell a bunch of books to credulous laypeople. Predictably, when the scientific community politely pushes back on his bullshit, he throws a toddler tantrum. I wonder what will happen if someone exposes him in a not so polite manner? Let's find out.
The video :
Introduction
Avi Loeb is an Israeli-American theoretical physicist who holds a prestigious position at Harvard University. He is a highly accomplished scientist with a strong publication record in traditional astrophysics. However, his recent work and public commentary have made him a controversial figure. Loeb is a leading proponent of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, and his hypotheses about interstellar objects—such as ʻOumuamua and the CNEOS 2014-01-08 meteor—being potential alien technology have garnered both significant media attention and sharp criticism from his scientific peers. This report provides a detailed overview of Loeb’s scientific work, the controversies surrounding his claims, the Galileo Project he founded to find extraterrestrial artifacts, his political and personal associations, and the intersections between his scientific pursuits and his views on religion and Zionism.
Mainstream Scientific Career and Publications
Before his controversial work on ʻOumuamua, Avi Loeb was a highly respected and prolific astrophysicist with over 1,000 scientific papers to his name (1). His mainstream research focused on a wide range of topics, including the formation of the first stars and galaxies, and the evolution of massive black holes.
Early Work on Microlensing: In 1992, he and a collaborator suggested that exoplanets could be detected through gravitational microlensing (53).
Black Hole Research: Loeb's work on black holes includes predictions about how a hot spot in orbit around a black hole would appear, which were later confirmed by the GRAVITY instrument on the Very Large Telescope (53). He also founded Harvard's prestigious Black Hole Initiative in 2016, an interdisciplinary program that brought together scientists to study the phenomenon (40, 44).
Early Universe: His research also delved into the early universe, where he addressed how and when the first stars and black holes formed and the effects they had on the young universe. This work was highly regarded and published in prestigious journals like Nature (1).
This extensive and respected body of work provides a stark contrast to his more recent, speculative claims, which critics argue represents a significant departure from his established career.
Pseudoscience and Scientific Controversy
Loeb's most controversial claims center on interstellar objects like ʻOumuamua and the CNEOS 2014-01-08 meteor. He has speculated that these objects could be alien technology (1). The broader scientific consensus, however, is that these objects are likely natural phenomena, such as a comet-like body altered by warming or an object made of nitrogen ice. Critics argue that Loeb's public statements and media appearances sensationalize the science and bypass the standard process of peer review, which requires "extraordinary evidence for extraordinary claims" (1). Loeb, in turn, argues that the scientific establishment is too conservative and stifles innovative thought.
The YouTube channel Professor Dave has also accused Loeb of being a "grifting fraud" who leverages his position at Harvard and manipulates the media into publicizing "paper-thin claims" outside of his expertise (7). According to Professor Dave, when faced with criticism, Loeb portrays himself as a victim silenced by the establishment, similar to Galileo. He claims that Loeb has "abandoned legitimate scientific processes" in favor of "generating public hype and book sales" for books like Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth and Interstellar: The Search for Extraterrestrial Life and Our Future in the Stars (7).
A new study presented at the Lunar and Planetary Science Conference suggests that the seismic activity previously attributed to the CNEOS 2014-01-08 meteor was actually caused by a truck driving past a seismometer, contradicting the conclusions of a 2019 paper co-authored by Loeb. Loeb used the seismic data to pinpoint a landing site for the meteor and recovered small metallic pieces, or "spherules," which he suspected were from the extraterrestrial object. However, the new research indicates that Loeb's team used the wrong signal and was looking in the wrong place. The meteor's actual landing spot was likely 100 miles away from where Loeb's team searched, and the seismic signal was more consistent with a nearby moving truck (8, 30).
Books: A Blend of Science and Speculation
Loeb's public persona and controversial hypotheses are largely built on his books, Extraterrestrial: The First Sign of Intelligent Life Beyond Earth and Interstellar: The Search for Extraterrestrial Life and Our Future in the Stars. These books have received a mixed critical reception.
"Extraterrestrial" (2021): In this book, Loeb argues that the simplest explanation for ʻOumuamua's anomalous behavior—such as its acceleration without a cometary tail—is that it was an alien technological artifact, possibly a "lightsail." Critical reviews acknowledge his compelling narrative and philosophical musings, but many fault the book for drawing "extraordinary conclusions from very little data" (54). While some praised his courage for challenging scientific orthodoxy, others pointed out that the book's core thesis is stretched thin by anecdotal evidence and memoir-like passages (55).
"Interstellar" (2023): This book expands on the theme of extraterrestrial life and argues for humanity's need to become an interstellar species. Critics have described it as "a fairly disorganized, rambling affair" that leaps between topics and metaphors, which distracts from the solid points he makes about academic dynamics and the stifling of novelty (54). The book explores thought-provoking philosophical ideas, but some critics note that his arguments can go beyond the supporting scientific data (54).
The Galileo Project
In response to this criticism, Loeb founded the Galileo Project at Harvard (1). The project's stated goal is to conduct a transparent, scientific search for extraterrestrial technology. It plans to use a network of telescopes and other sensors to collect and analyze data on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAPs) and interstellar objects (3). The project aims to make its data publicly available to ensure scientific scrutiny and publish its findings in peer-reviewed journals (3). The project is funded by private philanthropists and is backed by several "billionaire-backed tech tycoons" (48, 49, 50). Loeb's associate, Eric Weinstein, is also a member of the research team for the project (1, 9).
The project's team includes several researchers with various titles. Avi Loeb is the Head of the project. The research team includes members such as Eric Masson, a System Architect/Tech Lead; Amir Siraj, who is the Director of Interstellar Object Studies; Mitch Randall, Chief Science Officer at Ascendant AI; Garry Nolan, a professor at Stanford University; and Gary Melnick, from the Center for Astrophysics at Harvard & Smithsonian. Other members include Vikram Ravi, an Assistant Professor of Astronomy at Caltech; Andrew Rush, President & CEO of Copernicus Space Corporation; Forrest Schultz, an Optics and Opto-mechanical engineer; and postdoctoral fellows Richard Cloete and Laura Domine (3, 24, 25).
Government and Defense Connections
Avi Loeb's work on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAPs) has a connection to the Pentagon, but his research project is funded by private donors. In 2023, Loeb co-authored a draft research report on UAPs with a director from the Pentagon's All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO) (28). In 2025, he published an essay advocating for a "UAP-Manhattan Project" to be funded by Congress with a billion dollars, arguing it would benefit national security (29). He has publicly stated that his Galileo Project, which launched in 2021, is not affiliated with any governmental or military organizations and receives no funding from them (26). His work has, however, been tied to official government reports on UAPs, and in 2025, he visited the Pentagon to discuss his ideas for a government-funded research effort (27).
Friends and Associates
Loeb is associated with individuals who also express skepticism toward mainstream institutions. A key example is Eric Weinstein, a mathematician with a PhD from Harvard, and a managing director at Thiel Capital (2, 9). Weinstein is known for coining the term "Intellectual Dark Web," a group of commentators who challenge what they see as the "gated institutional narrative" of mainstream media and academia (2). The term was coined as a joke and popularized by New York Times opinion editor Bari Weiss (2, 9).
Eric Weinstein has publicly acknowledged that he knew Jeffrey Epstein and once had a meeting with him in Epstein's Manhattan townhouse around 2004 (11). According to RationalWiki, Weinstein's public persona is based on his belief that he and his ideas have been overlooked by a "nefarious scientific establishment." He promoted his own "Theory of Everything," called "Geometric Unity," for years before releasing a draft paper. The paper was met with silence and criticism, with some noting significant technical gaps. The article also mentions his controversial political and social views, including his support for his brother's anti-vaccination claims, and a conspiratorial belief that experts are compromised (16). He has also proposed a "Theory of Everything" called "Geometric Unity," which he first presented in a 2013 lecture at Oxford University (9). He was criticized for not publishing the equations for the theory, and later released a paper in 2021, which he described as a "work of entertainment" (9). The theory has been met with skepticism and criticism from physicists and mathematicians (9). The YouTube channel Professor Dave has a video debunking the Weinstein brothers, in which he claims that Eric has a "persecution complex" and has promoted a non-peer-reviewed theory that has been disproven by mathematicians (9).
Peter Thiel, a billionaire venture capitalist and co-founder of PayPal, has also been a prominent figure in this network. According to RationalWiki, he is described as a libertarian and an influential figure in Silicon Valley who has funded Republican politicians, including anti-gay figures, despite being openly gay himself. He is also known for funding lawsuits that led to the bankruptcy of Gawker Media.
The article also notes that he has made controversial "anti-woke" startup investments and that he employed Eric Weinstein as the managing director of Thiel Capital (17).
Bret Weinstein, Eric's brother, is also a prominent figure in the "Intellectual Dark Web." His public profile rose after a controversy at The Evergreen State College (TESC), where he objected to a new campus tradition and then claimed his life was in danger. This incident, which was amplified by right-wing media, led to him receiving a $500,000 settlement from the college to resign. Since then, he has used his platform to spread misinformation, notably about COVID-19 and HIV/AIDS (15).
In February 2024, during an appearance on the Joe Rogan Experience podcast, Bret Weinstein was criticized for promoting dangerous and false ideas about HIV/AIDS to an audience of millions (12). The American Foundation for AIDS Research has stated that Weinstein agreed with a false claim that "party drugs" were an "important factor in AIDS," and that he made the erroneous statement that some people with AIDS were not infected with HIV (12). Claims that COVID-19 vaccines caused 17 million deaths, which have been promoted by Bret Weinstein, have been identified as false by Politifact (13). The article states that multiple studies, including one by the World Health Organization, show that the vaccines actually saved millions of lives. Another Politifact article also debunks the claim that the spike protein from COVID-19 vaccines is "toxic" or "cytotoxic," noting that U.S. public health authorities and vaccine experts say there is no evidence to support this claim (14). Bret Weinstein and his wife, Heather Heying, have also promoted the use of ivermectin as a preventative and treatment for COVID-19, despite dubious evidence (15).
Another video by Professor Dave refutes claims made by physicist Sabine Hossenfelder, who he alleges is a "fraud" spreading anti-establishment propaganda and a "fake defense" of Eric Weinstein (10). According to this video, Hossenfelder has argued that academia is a "planned economy" and questioned the value of publicly funded science. The video suggests that Peter Thiel may be the "paymaster" behind the propaganda pushed by both Weinstein and Hossenfelder (10).
Eric Weinstein also hosts a podcast called "The Portal" (9). Both Weinstein and Loeb have used platforms like podcasts to discuss what they perceive as a lack of open-mindedness in modern scientific circles (6).
Loeb also has a professional and personal relationship with the renowned physicist Stephen Hawking. In April 2016, Loeb hosted Hawking at his home for a Passover dinner and for the inauguration of the Black Hole Initiative at Harvard, which Loeb founded (40, 43, 44). They also served together on the advisory committee for the Breakthrough Starshot project, which aims to send a fleet of miniature probes to another star system (43, 45, 51). This project is also backed by philanthropists, including Mark Zuckerberg and his wife, Priscilla Chan (49, 52).
Stephen Hawking, however, is posthumously connected to Jeffrey Epstein. In unsealed court documents from 2024, an email from Epstein to his associate Ghislaine Maxwell was revealed in which Epstein offered a reward to anyone who could disprove an allegation from one of his accusers, Virginia Giuffre, that Hawking had participated in an "underage orgy" (41, 42, 46). Hawking had attended a science conference funded by Epstein on his private Caribbean island in 2006, before Epstein was first charged with sex crimes (42, 46). It is important to note that Hawking has not been accused of a crime related to Epstein's activities (41, 46). While this links Hawking and Loeb's associate Eric Weinstein to Epstein, there is no evidence to suggest that Avi Loeb had any direct connection to Epstein.
Christianity and the Search for Extraterrestrial Life
The growing public interest in UFOs and Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAPs) has sparked a renewed discussion among Christian theologians and media outlets about the existence of extraterrestrial life. While the Bible does not directly mention aliens, Christian thinkers have debated the possibility for centuries. Some, like the organization Answers in Genesis, argue that the Bible's focus on Earth and humanity makes extraterrestrial life unlikely (33). They suggest that God created Earth specifically to be inhabited and that Jesus's incarnation was for the salvation of humanity alone. Other theologians, however, have proposed that the discovery of intelligent alien life would not contradict core Christian doctrines. Instead, it would require a reformulation of theological concepts, such as creation and salvation, to account for a vast, diverse universe (34, 35).
This topic has gained traction in Christian media, with some outlets exploring the implications of government UAP disclosures (36, 37). Some apologists and commentators have even proposed that the UFO phenomenon may be linked to spiritual warfare, suggesting that these entities could be demonic beings (38). They argue that this narrative serves as a distraction from spiritual realities and promotes a worldview that is not grounded in the Bible (38).
Avi Loeb's work has also intersected with this discourse. He has written about the connection between science and religion, suggesting that a sufficiently advanced extraterrestrial civilization could be seen as a form of "God" in a scientific context (31, 39). He has also engaged with Christian media, noting that the discovery of an "interstellar messenger" could usher in a "Messianic age" that unifies humanity (31). In a conversation with an editor from Christianity Today, he proposed that the search for extraterrestrial intelligence could be a way to attract more people to a congregation, suggesting a path for dialogue between science and faith (31). This engagement highlights a developing convergence of scientific curiosity and theological exploration regarding the cosmic neighborhood we may or may not share.
Zionism
Loeb, who is Israeli-American, has also expressed his views on Zionism. He has publicly criticized anti-Zionist sentiments, particularly among Jewish students at Harvard. In a 2024 op-ed, he argued that anti-Zionism is a form of animosity toward the existence of Israel (4). He has also linked the search for alien life to the conflict, suggesting that a discovery of a successful extraterrestrial civilization could provide a "shock therapy" to unite humanity and show the futility of fighting over territory on Earth (4).
This perspective is in contrast to the views of several international bodies. Francesca Albanese, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories, has accused Israel of actions that amount to "genocide" and "ethnic cleansing" in Gaza (18). Similarly, both Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have issued reports that condemn Israel's actions and have used terms such as "apartheid" and "genocide" to describe the situation, and both have called for accountability (18). Amnesty International has also publicly condemned the US sanctions against Francesca Albanese, calling it a "disgraceful affront to international justice" and a "shameless and transparent attack" on the principles of international law (18).
In a separate instance, a former head of Israel's space security program, Haim Eshed, claimed that extraterrestrials exist and have been in contact with the US and Israeli governments for years. Eshed claimed a "Galactic Federation" of aliens exists and that they have a secret underground base on Mars where they cooperate with US astronauts. He also asserted that former US President Donald Trump was aware of these aliens and was close to revealing their existence, but was stopped by the federation to prevent mass hysteria (19).
Spreading ZAKA Oct. 7 lies
Avi Loeb has been accused of amplifying the narrative of atrocities that have been linked to debunked claims from Zaka volunteers. These claims, which included stories of babies being beheaded, were widely circulated in the aftermath of the October 7th attack. The video "Avi Loeb is a Fraud Now" argues that he used these specific, emotionally charged claims to bolster his criticism of Harvard's response to the attacks and to portray a particular narrative of the events. This has led critics to accuse him of spreading misinformation that has since been retracted by many media outlets that initially reported it.
Zaka founder background
Yehuda Meshi-Zahav, the founder of Zaka, faced a widely reported sexual abuse scandal that came to public light in 2021, shortly before he was to receive the Israel Prize. The accusations, which he denied, involved the systematic abuse and exploitation of men, women, and children within his ultra-Orthodox community over several decades. These crimes were reportedly known to many, but a "code of silence" had kept them from being reported. Following the public outcry, a police investigation was launched, but it was never completed. Meshi-Zahav attempted suicide in April 2021 and died in June 2022 after being in a coma.
Interconnections
During a visit to Israel in late 2023, Avi Loeb met with Dan Blumberg, Chairman of the Israel Space Agency, and Dr. Yuval Steinitz, Chairman of Rafael, a major Israeli defense company. Both figures have connections to the government of Benjamin Netanyahu. Yuval Steinitz served as a longtime minister and close confidant of Netanyahu. Dan Blumberg is a renowned researcher who has also received praise from Netanyahu for his work in collaboration between academia, the military, and the cyber-industry (23).
Background in Israel
Loeb was born in Beit Hanan, Israel, in 1962, and was raised on a family farm (20, 21). At age 18, he was accepted into the elite Talpiot program of the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF), which allows recruits to pursue defense-related research in place of standard military service (20, 22). During this time, he obtained his BSc, MSc, and PhD in physics from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (20). He also performed research on a project that was the first international project supported by President Ronald Reagan's Strategic Defense Initiative (20, 22).
Loeb has made recent visits to Israel. A Medium article he wrote in late 2023 details a visit where he was at the Weizmann Institute of Science and had to seek shelter from a rocket attack (23). During this visit, he met with Dan Blumberg, Chairman of the Israel Space Agency, and Dr. Yuval Steinitz, Chairman of Rafael (23).
Conclusion
Avi Loeb is a complex and polarizing figure whose career trajectory highlights a key tension in modern science: the conflict between rigorous, evidence-based inquiry and the desire for bold, paradigm-shifting ideas. His path from a highly respected mainstream astrophysicist, known for his work on black holes and the early universe, to a public figure promoting speculative claims about alien technology is a central theme of his story (1, 53).
In response to sharp criticism from his peers, Loeb has used a variety of strategies to advance his agenda. He founded the Galileo Project, a privately funded initiative backed by billionaires like Mark Zuckerberg and others from his network, to conduct a transparent search for extraterrestrial artifacts outside of traditional academic institutions (49, 52). He has also actively courted media attention and engaged with high-profile figures like Eric Weinstein and the "Intellectual Dark Web," who share his skepticism of institutional narratives and experts (2, 9). This network, which includes individuals with controversial views and indirect ties to figures like Jeffrey Epstein through associates like Weinstein and the late Stephen Hawking, has helped to amplify his message (11, 46).
Loeb’s worldview is further shaped by his personal background in Israel, his service in the IDF, and his strong Zionist views, which he links to a cosmic perspective on humanity’s place in the universe (4, 22). He extends this philosophical approach to religion, suggesting that a sufficiently advanced alien civilization could be seen as a form of "God" or that a discovery could lead to a "Messianic age" that unifies humanity (31, 39). This blending of scientific speculation, ideological conviction, and philosophical musing allows him to position himself as a modern-day Galileo, a victim of a conservative scientific establishment. However, his critics argue that this narrative undermines the very scientific process he claims to champion, as his methods and conclusions often lack the rigorous, peer-reviewed evidence required for such extraordinary claims (7, 54).
Sources:
Avi Loeb - Wikipedia
Intellectual dark web - Wikipedia
The Galileo Project - Wikipedia
What Will Earth Look Like in a Million Years? | by Avi Loeb - Medium
Abraham (Avi) Loeb - Publications - The Academic Family Tree
Inside the Intellectual Dark Web, Eric Weinstein - YouTube
What is Avi Loeb Really All About? | Professor Dave Explains - YouTube
The truth about the Harvard astronomer’s ‘alien’ spherules - Big Think
The Debunking of the Weinstein Brothers - YouTube
The Hossenfelder Debunk - YouTube
The Portal: The Construct - Jeffrey Epstein - Apple Podcasts
Bret Weinstein - Wikipedia
COVID-19 vaccines saved lives, did not cause 17 million deaths | PolitiFact
No sign COVID-19 vaccines’ spike protein is ‘toxic’ or ‘cytotoxic’ | PolitiFact
Bret Weinstein - RationalWiki
Eric Weinstein - RationalWiki
Peter Thiel - RationalWiki
Francesca Albanese - Wikipedia; The Gaza Genocide in Five Crises - Taylor & Francis Online; USA: Sanctions against UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese are a disgraceful affront to international justice - Amnesty International
Former Israeli space security chief says aliens exist, and Trump knows about it - NBC News
Avi Loeb - Wikipedia
Autobiographical sketch Parents - Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian
Avi Loeb - American Friends of the Hebrew University
A Retreat from Harvard in the Holy Land | by Avi Loeb - Medium
Research Team | The Galileo Project
Fellows of the Galileo Project. The first two postdoctoral fellows of… | by Avi Loeb - Medium
Support Us | The Galileo Project
The Afterglow of a UAP Congressional Briefing | by Avi Loeb | Medium
Pentagon officials suggest alien mothership in our solar system could send mini probes to Earth | Fox News
A Vision for a UAP-Manhattan Project | by Avi Loeb | Medium
The rumblings that led to the 'alien spheres' probably came from a truck | Astronomy.com
Avi Loeb on Christianity Today and Aliens - Medium; How Aliens Can Unify Science and Religion - Mind Matters
Avi Loeb Strikes Back:Answering the Critics - Brian Keating | YouTube
Are There Aliens? A Christian Perspective - Answers in Genesis
On The Possibility of Extraterrestrials - Word On Fire
The Astrobiological Implications of God's Creation - Stand To Reason
The U.S. Government Is Taking UFOs Seriously - The Christian Century
A Christian Response to Government UFO Disclosures - The Gospel Coalition
Is the UFO Phenomenon Demonic? - Think Eternity
Is God an Advanced Scientist? - Avi Loeb | Medium
The Wonder of Avi Loeb - Smithsonian Magazine
Fact-check: Are Stephen Hawking and JImmy Kimmel on Epstein's list? - YouTube
Paedophile Jeffrey Epstein offered reward to disprove claims Stephen Hawking took part in orgy - Yahoo News
What Makes Us Human? | by Avi Loeb - Medium
It is a sad day for the world of physics and humanity - Harvard Astronomy Department
Stephen Hawking: We Probably Won't Find Aliens Anytime Soon | Live Science
What Unsealed Jeffrey Epstein Documents Say About Stephen Hawking - NDTV
Avi Loeb's Galileo Project Reaches for the Stars | Magazine - The Harvard Crimson
Philanthropy by Inspiration | by Avi Loeb | Medium
Billionaire-backed Harvard Prof. says science should take UFOs seriously - Business Insider
Avi Loeb's Galileo Project Reaches for the Stars | Magazine - The Harvard Crimson
What is Breakthrough Starshot? - Astronomy.com
Mark Zuckerberg, Priscilla Chan donate $100M to Breakthrough Starshot initiative - Business Insider
The Scientist Who Thinks Aliens Are Already Here - Popular Mechanics
The Scientist Who Thinks Aliens Are Already Here, and the Debate Around His Work - Time Magazine
Avi Loeb's Extraterrestrial is a compelling, but ultimately unconvincing, read - Ars Technica
